We’re now witnessing the 36th film in the overall franchise that is the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and things are in a state. While still good, it’s been a far rockier road than what came before in the pre-“Endgame” era. From a series that once made almost billion dollar hits out of “Ant-Man” and the “Guardians of the Galaxy” to one that can barely make a “Captain America” film break even, it’s gonna take an interesting group to save the day. And while there have certainly been bright spots in the past few years, “Thunderbolts*” emerges as one of the brightest and most character driven adventures the MCU has ever had.
Things suck for Yelena Belova, played by Florence Pugh (“Midsommar,” “Little Women (2019)”). After the death of her sister Natasha Romanov aka Black Widow in the events of “Avengers: Endgame,” she’s taken to contract work for shady CIA director Valentina Allegra de Fontaine, played by Julia Louis-Dreyfus (“Seinfeld,” “Veep”). After her last mission goes haywire, she finds herself reluctantly teaming up with fellow disgraced antiheroes John Walker, played by Wyatt Russell (“Overlord,” “Monarch: Legacy of Monsters”), Ghost, played by Hannah John-Kamen (“Killjoys,” “Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City”), Red Guardian, played by David Harbour (“Stranger Things,” “Violent Night”), and Bucky Barnes, played by Sebastian Stan (“The Apprentice,” “Pam & Tommy”), as well as the mysterious amnesiac Bob, played by Lewis Pullman (“Bad Times at the El Royale,” “Lessons in Chemistry"), to stop Valentia’s mysterious agenda and find self-fulfillment again.
This is director Jake Schreier’s (“Beef,” “Paper Towns”) biggest budget project thus far, but the scope of the tale doesn’t diminish his skill with character-driven stories in any way. Ironically, the bickering of the main troupe and their issues throughout have more in common with “Beef” than the previous MCU projects. Writers Eric Pearson (“Thor: Ragnarok,” “Black Widow”) and Joanna Calo (“The Bear,” “Hacks”) build each member of the bunch with a slow burn of character development that makes each one engaging to spend time with. It’s a feat to turn characters that have their roots in secondary roles to the stars of the show, and Pearson and Calo manage to pull it off. This also ties into the film’s emotional climax, which works wonders and manages to make this one of the more emotionally impactful tales in the recent MCU, and possibly ever. There are remarkably few fights here (though they certainly do exist) and it's refreshing to see a film like this go for a more emotional ending instead of trading fisticuffs.
Pugh absolutely steals the show, which shouldn’t be surprising given her extensive resume or her love of the character. She gives an incredibly physical performance that never undercuts the emotional journey she takes Yelena on. Russell and John-Kamen are also excellent, levelling their characters up from b-players to legitimate leading types in their own right, with Russell turning in a surprisingly effective emotional turn. Harbour continues to deliver more of the same lovable oafish charm he had in spades in “Black Widow” and Louis-Dreyfus is a fun villainous role that’s only slightly undercut given the easy associate with her classic leading role in “Veep.” The film’s biggest secret weapon though is Pullman. His work here is deeply emotionally effective and far deeper than one might expect. It’s a testament to the script and direction, but his ability to have this character balance between comic relief and deep emotional pathos, without either ever feeling forced or countering the other, is nothing short of impressive.
There’s a strong sense of practicality throughout the entire film, from the fight sequences to the strong cinematography from Andrew Droz Palermo (“A Ghost Story,” “The Green Knight”). There’s a muted look to the entire film that feels purposeful given the circumstances and the adventure these characters are sent on. Things get wonky towards the end, intentionally so, and the look of the film keeps it up the entire way. Even the action feels more physical. Not necessarily grounded, as there’s still plenty of superhero shenanigans going on, but a surprisingly large amount of the film zeroes in on hand-to-hand combat, with remarkably few fights compared to the grand superhero film landscape. The musical score from Son Lux (“Everything Everywhere All at Once”) is absolutely exceptional, putting a firm stamp on the genre, using the grand strings and bombastic nature of scores typical of the genre to sneak in something more complicated and inventive.
It’s hard to state that very specific special sauce that makes this film exceptionally without spoiling a large part of it but suffice it to say that “Thunderbolts*” has what most of these films have been missing for quite a while: heart. And it has it in spades. Outside of the recent “Black Panther” and “Guardians of the Galaxy” films, there’s been almost a reflex to push against any sort of inherent emotional vulnerability in the MCU. Schreier bucks that trend, and as a result creates something closer to those original films that started it all. Yes, there’s plenty of smashing, crashing, and big fights to entertain, but the genuine humanity and vulnerability at the core of this team keeps you invested the entire time. By the time things end, something special has happened: these anti-heroes didn’t go for the throat, they went for the heart.
“Thunderbolts*” is the absolute surprise of the year so far. What started as a ragtag group of b-tier leftover antagonists in a borderline “Suicide Squad” rip-off has somehow emerged as one of the most emotionally satisfying adventures the MCU has ever seen. By keeping things grounded in pseudo-reality, as well as pumping in plenty of excellent cinematography and music, Jason Schreier turns an already sharp script into an adventure that will surprise you with just how much you care about this team. Marvel has caught a new bolt of thunder in a bottle. 4.5/5