Calling a director like Darren Aronofsky (“The Whale,” “The Wrestler”) a “general audience” filmmaker would be like calling extra-spicy siracha a “light condiment.” While his films are beloved and acclaimed, he is still the director behind “Requiem for a Dream,” “Pi,” “Black Swan,” and “mother!” to name just a few. So, to see him direct a crime thriller starring Austin Butler (“Elvis (2022),” “Dune Part Two”) might be a bit of a leap. But make no mistake, even if “Caught Stealing” is the most audience friendly film he’s yet made, it's still far from an easy pill to swallow.
Set in 1998 New York City, the film follows Hank, played by Butler, a high school baseball star turned bartender puttering along in life. He spends his days drinking, bartending, and hanging out with his girlfriend Yvonne, played by Zoë Kravitz (“The Batman (2022),” “Big Little Lies”). After his next-door neighbor Russ, played by Matt Smith (“Doctor Who,” “House of the Dragon”), has to rush back home to London, Hank finds himself caring for Russ’s cat in the meantime. Things quickly take a turn though after Hank finds himself hunted by police detective Roman, played by Regina King (“The Boondocks,” “If Beale Street Could Talk”), Hebrew gangsters Lipa and Shmully Drucker, played by Liev Schreiber (“Doubt,” “Ray Donovan”) and Vincent D'Onofrio (“Men in Black,” “Daredevil (2015)”) respectively, Cuban gangster Colorado, played by Benito Martínez Ocasio (“Bullet Train,” “Happy Gilmore 2”), and two Russian gangsters Aleksei and Pavel, played by Yuri Kolokolnikov (“Game of Thrones,” “The Americans”) and Nikita Kukushkin (“Captain Volkonogov Escaped,” “Attraction”) respectively, all of whom are looking for Russ.
It's a fairly simple premise for a crime caper like this, and screenwriter Charlie Huston (“Powers”) uses that simplicity to stack bodies and misunderstandings as high as possible to further complicate Hank’s adventure. It’s the sort of film that doesn’t have a mystery at its core, rather everyone withholding information from each other. It means that each moment feels exceptionally tense, as if a backstab could occur at the drop of a hat. Huston does an excellent job bringing his own novel to the big screen, and he and Aronofsky makes great use of the material together. Most notably, it feels like a true “New York” film in a way one hasn’t in quite a while. As opposed to most others that use the landmarks for set dressing, Aronofsky gets into the streets and alleyways and lets it all breathe. There’s not a single shot of the Statue of Liberty or Grand Central Station or any place like that, but it feels more “New York” than a movie that just shows you New York.
Butler makes for a great patsy here, playing Hank’s naivety for the situation to a great effect. He never feels like an idiot or clueless; he’s the kind of guy who can piece together what’s going on but genuinely is mistaken in his position in it all. It’s a great kind of role, as opposed to films that have their “good guy” actually be a not so good guy after all. It adds meat and tension to his role in the story and to Butler’s performance as things go on. King is a fantastic force of nature against him, peppering her role with classic bits of New York cop attitude and dialogue. Smith is a delightfully fun British crust punk and is so much fun to hate. Ironically, the film’s two best performances are two that deserve far more screen time: Kravitz, Schreiber, and D’Onofrio are all great but leave you wishing they had a larger role in the film as a whole given their excellence and chemistry with Butler.
As Aronofsky and cinematographer Matthew Libatique (“Black Swan,” “A Star is Born (2018)”) dip and weave through alleyways and supermarkets, the wonderful score from composer Rob Simonsen (“Ghostbusters: Afterlife,” “Deadpool & Wolverine”) and rock band Idles worms its way into your ears and sets the entire escapade alight. The film certainly looks the part, bloodied, beaten, and tattered, and yet Aronofsky’s more brutal touches are here in full force. While not as psychologically brutal or full of gore as his previous works, it's a film that’s brutal in its story. No one is safe in this tale, and it straddles the line between emotional devastation and catharsis. It makes the journey feel worth it, knowing lives are on the line as opposed to being a film wherein there’s an absence of danger. That being said, Aronosfky isn’t the sort of director to hide any of the brutality even in a lighter fare film. Just know that, if a character gets shot, you’re going to see them get shot before, during, and after.
It’s odd to call a film like this, a dark comedy crime thriller from Darren Aronofsky, a crowd pleaser, but it's as close as we’re likely to get from him. Because for all its tension and toughness, this is a film wherein he and Huston clearly just want to take you on a wild ride through New York City. It just so happens that this ride is bumpier and bloodier than you might expect. But with a cast, musical score, and generally grimy look like this, it's a ride well worth taking. If you can stomach a few dead bodies. 4.5/5